With the results of the 2026 midterm elections, Islam is suddenly front and center. What does that mean and where do we go from here?
Hi, I’m Rex Rogers and this is episode #288 of Discerning What Is Best, a podcast applying unchanging biblical principles in a rapidly changing world, and a Christian worldview to current issues and everyday life.
Most Americans don’t think much about Islam, unless maybe during news about the Iran war or perhaps a terrorist incident somewhere.
But two developments in fall 2026 is putting Islam on the map for many Americans: demonstrations in France, beginning in September and continuing, and the US midterm election in which Abdul Al-Sayed was elected to the US Senate from Michigan.
In France, protests have raged for a month, growing in a manner that includes a broad cross-section of the discontented. Muslim immigrants, while not the only protest participants and not alone responsible for the riots and street anarchy, are nevertheless present and evident in media coverage. Many protesters wave not the tri-color flag of France but the red-triangled Palestinian flag, a banner that has become an international symbol of protest Western civilization. This ongoing upheaval, which is now also occurring in Italy, Albania, and other European countries is also triggering counterdemonstrations. The story has resulted in more media attention to mass migration in Europe and to Islamic cultural behaviors and expectations.
In the US, the election, November 4, 2025, of Zohran Mamdani as Mayor of New York City, who is a self-avowed Muslim and Democratic Socialist was a startling occurrence in America’s leading city. During the fall 2026 midterms, Abdul Al-Sayed’s election to the US Senate, again a self-avowed Muslim, was another startling development. When Al-Sayed is sworn in, he will be the first Muslim to serve in the US Senate.
As of the fall 2026 midterm elections, “a record 255 Muslims now serve in elected office at nearly every level of government in the U.S., according to the Council on American-Islamic Relations. The largest share of Muslim elected leadership is in local government.
The 98 Muslim council members account for 38.4% of all Islamic elected officials.” Muslim officials will serve in 21 states, with eight set to serve in Congress.
So, with Abdul Al-Sayed now in the US Senate, Mamdani holding forth in New York City, Congresswoman Ilan Omar, despite her recent legal troubles, still influential, and Islamic communities in Texas and New Jersey expanding, we are going to hear more about Islam.
For perspective, Islam is generally considered the fastest-growing major religion in the United States, due to immigration, higher fertility rates, and conversions.
The Muslim population in North America grew by about 52% from 2010 to 2020, according to Pew’s global religious-demographics study. There are approximately 5.5 million Muslims in the United States, a number that has more than doubled in the last two decades. More than half of the country’s Muslim population is concentrated in the five states New York, California, Illinois, New Jersey and Texas, a striking geographic concentration that signals where growth and political influence are most likely to be felt.
The best nationwide data come from the U.S. Mosque Survey found 2,106 mosques in 2010, 2,769 mosques in 2020. That’s an increase of 663 mosques over 10 years, or about 66 new mosques per year on average. The estimate now is just over 3,000 mosques in the USA.
Now the simple existence of Muslim citizens in the USA is not per se the issue.
The concerning question is the same as for any group that is invited into the country—will they integrate, assimilate? Will they reinforce E pluribus unum?
The short answer is that most will. Many Muslim Americans are hardworking, honest, law-abiding people who appreciate the country of their residence. On the other hand, a certain smaller number are not, and often they are committed to anti-American ideals and other values that are incompatible with American democratic pluralism. Some are willing to be violent in their zeal to advance their ideology. This percentage of those who reject the American ethos and system are often called “Islamists” in an effort to distinguish them from peace-loving Muslims.
Now, as soon as these points are made, certain pushback complaints are invariably loudly proclaimed:
1. Not just criticisms but even comments about Muslims or Islam are labeled “Islamophobic.” Somehow, any observation whatsoever is considered bias, discriminatory, or worse, hate. Of course it is possible to make hateful comments, but simple disagreements are not ipso facto intolerance. In fact, they are what First Amendment freedom of speech is all about.
2. Not just criticisms but even comments about Muslims are deemed “racist.” Problem is Muslim is not a race. It is the name for religious adherents of Islam, and there are Muslims of every race in virtually every country of the world. Asking questions about Islam or Muslims is not racism.
Until now, people, politicians, media anchors including on Fox, and many Christian leaders have not been tuned into Islam except maybe when something blows up. And they know very little about what it really stands for as a political ideology. And trust me, if leaders know little about Islam as a political ideology, John Q. Public knows even less.
News anchors who are now asking politicians like Mamdani or Al-Sayed questions about their religious beliefs don’t know what to ask, how to ask, or how to follow up when they get glib non-answer responses.
And many media elites are burdened with multicultural assumptions wherein they’ve been taught all cultures, and particularly all religions, are relative. None are better than another. None are right or wrong. And among most of the intelligentsia in the West and the US, they’ve drunk the Kool-Aid that Western civilization—despite all its accomplishments, its freedoms like no others, its prosperity, and its potential—somehow Western civilization is suspect, it is morally indefensible because, really, it’s based on white supremacy and is nothing but a settler, colonialist, imperialist civilization built upon greed. So how dare we, how can we ask questions about what Islamists want to do because, hey, we are no better and in fact worse?
And of course, except for a few outlets, the media anchors don’t want to sound “Far Right.” This is happening in France and Europe right now. Anyone who wonders aloud whether Muslim mass migration and has anything to do with the social anarchy taking place is immediately labeled “Far Right.” But asking a question is not condemnation. It is investigation, looking for truth.
I said we are going to hear more about Islam now because Mamdani and now Al-Sayed’s elections may have—hopefully has—awakened the sleeping giant. Until now, Americans have largely been unaware, uninterested, uninformed, and unmoved by what scholars call “Islamization” or “Islamification,” the process Islamists call “Grand Jihad”—check the record of 1400 years—by which Islam commands Muslims to immigrate, populate, agitate, and dominate in nations it wishes to engage.
Jihadists have used bombs, or jets as in 9/11. This method has not gone away but it is ineffectual. What Islamists find more useful now is not bombs but babies and ballots.
Muslims in the United States average roughly 2.5 children per woman, which is higher than the national total fertility rate of about 1.60 children per woman. The replacement rate, the number needed to keep a population growing, is 2.1, and the US, like all Western nations is falling behind. Meanwhile, the Muslim population expands, as it is doing in Europe. Demography is destiny they say. Do the math.
Ballots? Well, we’ve talked about that. Muslim politicians made tremendous strides this last election.
Allow me to re-emphasize: my comments are not meant to demean Muslim citizens. They are just people like anyone else. No question, many American Muslims love this country, have fought for it, and simply want to live their lives with their families in peace and prosperity. And like followers of any religious faith, including Christianity, there are informed and active followers, casual followers, and simply cultural followers who, truth be told, don’t know much about their own religion.
Our concern is to note that with the results of the last election, we’re going to hear more about Islam, and we should. For example, my social media has been blowing up with videos and posts about Islam in the US and in Europe. It’s an interesting awakening, the results of which remain to be seen. Will Americans continue to seek to learn more about Islam and Islamic civilization, or will the flurry around the election fade and we’ll return to our ignorance is bliss assumptions?
I am hoping this flurry continues, because it’s a matter of stewardship of the American future.
Well, we’ll see you again soon. This podcast is about Discerning What Is Best. If you find this thought-provoking and helpful, follow us on your favorite podcast platform. For more Christian commentary, see my website, r-e-x-m as in Martin, that’s rexmrogers.com, or check my YouTube channel @DrRexRogers.
And remember, it is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm.
© Rex M. Rogers – All Rights Reserved, 2026
*This podcast blog may be reproduced in whole or in part with a full attribution statement. Contact me or read more commentary on current issues and events at www.rexmrogers.com/ or my YouTube channel @DrRexRogers or connect with me at www.linkedin.com/in/rexmrogers.
Given America’s First Amendment freedom of religion, should American Muslims be limited in any way in terms of their beliefs and practices?
Hi, I’m Rex Rogers and this is episode #242 of Discerning What Is Best, a podcast applying unchanging biblical principles in a rapidly changing world, and a Christian worldview to current issues and everyday life.
In the 21st Century, Muslim immigration to the West, including the United States, has skyrocketed, and many of these immigrants are Muslims from distinctly Muslim-dominated countries and cultures.
Like all immigrants, they bring with them their religious worldviews and their cultures. Some, like millions of immigrants before them, have eagerly sought a better life and worked to assimilate in classic melting pot fashion. Others have resisted assimilation and acculturation, have consciously sought to perpetuate their cultural and religious practices they brought from home, and tend to live in balkanized communities separated from other citizens. The estimated 10 million immigrants who came to the US during the recent Biden Administration, many but not all Muslim, are part of this story.
In this piece, I want to think with you about freedom of religion, and when, if ever, it can or should be restricted.
The US Constitution’s Bill of Rights begins with the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
This is a precious, and in world history, unprecedented guarantee of human rights. We do not ever want to treat it lightly or deny it’s protection of freedom of religion without considerable due process and careful thinking about community standards in a truly free society.
Numerous American voices are becoming concerned about not simply the number of Muslim immigrants who’ve come to the US, but
a) whether they will assimilate, and
b) whether their religious beliefs are compatible with a free society.
The challenge of Islam is that it is both a religion and a political ideology, one that seeks political control when it becomes dominant. Muslim adherents embrace Islam along a continuum of theological, political, and cultural ideas, some radical or extremist, some moderate. So, your conclusions about “what is a Muslim and what do they believe” depend upon which subgroup you may be examining along this continuum.
“Muslims” are but followers of their religion, which is Islam. They are just people, who, like all other human beings, carry their beliefs in a complex and confusing, sometimes contradictory, manner. There are indeed “moderate” or simply nominal Muslims the world over, ones who are not radical, do not act on religious violence, and simply seek to live their lives in peace. But there are many others who act out—often dangerously—extreme ideological views.
With increasing numbers of Muslim immigrants flooding the country during the Biden Administration, some American commentators began to suggest Islam be banned in the US, while others focused upon banning specifically Sharia law or radical Islam.
Some commentators argue Muslims intentionally use American human rights protections to advance their belief systems in the US, beliefs that are anti-freedom.
Charlie Kirk famously tweeted, “Islam is not compatible with western civilization.” Some argue Islam is the #1 enemy of the civilized world. In other words, Islam as a religion is an existential threat to the values upon which American experience was built and flourished.
Islam and distinguished Middle East expert, author Raymond Ibrahim, argues Islam is not free. Islam as presented in the Quran is totalitarian, inherently expansionist, i.e., Jihad, adherents are prepared to kill to achieve its aims - antithetical to everything Western society stands for—opposes free speech, free enterprise, freedom to practice or not to practice any religion, freedom of assembly, free press, fundamental human and civil rights; hatred of non-Muslims, “infidels,” is commanded, the Quran allows deception of infidels as needed, i.e., lying, and the call to violence and the justification for it are explicitly stated in the Quran. In Professor Ibrahim’s view, there may be moderate Muslims, but Islam is not moderate.
Let’s take a step back a moment for perspective. Throughout American history various religious groups have attempted to practice certain beliefs that, eventually, the Supreme Court of the United States disallowed, saying one can believe anything religiously, but not every action motivated by religion is immune from regulation.
For example, in Reynolds v. United States (1879), Mormon defendants argued plural marriage, i.e., bigamy, was required by their faith. But the Supreme Court drew a sharp line:
The Court noted that if religious belief excused illegal conduct, “each citizen would become a law unto himself.”
In Prince v. Massachusetts (1944), the Supreme court reviewed numerous lower-court blood transfusion cases involving Jehovah’s Witnesses. The Court said, parents may be martyrs themselves, but they may not make martyrs of their children. In other words, adults generally may refuse blood transfusions for themselves on religious grounds. But courts may override parents’ refusals for their children. The bottom line is the Supreme Court’s reasoning can be summarized like this:
Should The Muslim "Call to Prayer" be banned from public spaces in America? And should Muslims be stopped from blocking public roadways in order to bow in prayer five times per day? Dearborn, Michigan, nearby Hamtramck, considered to be America’s first majority-Muslim city, Paterson, NJ have authorized the call to prayer. Minneapolis, Minnesota became the first major U.S. city to allow the call to prayer five times daily, modifying its noise ordinance in 2023.
Loud "Allahu Akbar" calls blasting from speakers can be disturbing to public spaces. No other religion demands this — churches don't shut down roads for prayer or bells, synagogues don't amplify services over neighborhoods. Bans aren't official city-wide policies but rather the result of applying general noise ordinances to religious practices. Blocking public thoroughfares has long been denied back to the protests of the 1960s.
So, what does this mean for Islam in the USA? It means that Muslims who have become American citizens enjoy and should enjoy the same rights and protections regarding freedom of religion as any other American. It also means that certain Islamist religious practices, should they become threatening to third parties or should the state develop a compelling interest in the outcomes, may be regulated without violating Muslim American’s First Amendment rights and certainly without banning Islam.
I have no desire to deny American citizen Muslims their right to freedom of religion. While I am not Muslim and while I disagree with what Islam proclaims and while I certainly reject radical Islam or Islamist views, I do not want to deny construction of mosques. I do not believe the Quran supersedes the Bible, but I do not want to ban this book.
In my view, freedom of religion was inaugurated in the Garden of Eden when God created Adam and Eve in his image with reasoning capacity and a moral consciousness, then permitted them to decide. God commanded them to obey and left them to choose, to exercise their freedom to believe and obey God, or not.
I do believe, though, that certain Islamist beliefs are inimical to free society and should be prohibited in Western civilization, specifically the USA, e.g., honor killings, female genital mutilation, child marriage, bigamy, jihad, forced religious conversion, misogyny, or obviously religiously motivated rape gangs like those occurring in Europe.
I also believe restricting others’ religious or cultural practices, which ostensibly offend some Muslims, e.g., not permitting dogs in neighborhoods where Muslims may live or shutting down Christmas celebrations or making haram foods like pork or alcohol illegal at local supermarkets near Muslim populations, are unnecessary religious impositions upon a pluralistic culture.
For e pluribus unum to work, we must be able to debate religious ideas in the civic public square and determine truth based upon the merits of views, not coercion or silencing. This is the essence of a free society. All Americans are welcome to join this conversation.
Well, we’ll see you again soon. This podcast is about Discerning What Is Best.
If you find this thought-provoking and helpful, follow us on your favorite podcast platform. For more Christian commentary, see my website, r-e-x-m as in Martin, that’s rexmrogers.com, or check my YouTube channel @DrRexRogers.
And remember, it is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm.
© Rex M. Rogers – All Rights Reserved, 2026
*This podcast blog may be reproduced in whole or in part with a full attribution statement. Contact me or read more commentary on current issues and events at www.rexmrogers.com/ or my YouTube channel @DrRexRogers, or connect with me at www.linkedin.com/in/rexmrogers.
Hussein Hajji Wario’s own story, Cracks in the Crescent (2009), is a truly remarkable testimony of God’s grace. Born and raised in Kenya, Wario grew up in a devout Sunni Muslim family, attended madrassa (Islamic primary school), and became a muadhin (a person who calls Muslims to pray). But just prior to beginning high school, Wario came to saving faith in Jesus Christ, a conversion that both changed his life forever and the world he lived in immediately.
Wario endured more than five years of persecution. His family rejected him, more than one brother attempted to beat him, a sister tried to poison him, members of his small tribal community berated him, chased him, threw rocks at him, stole his property, lied about him, and conspired with local authorities to arrest or otherwise harass him. While his family enjoyed financial means they refused to continue supporting his education. Yet God provided finances, a few Christian friends who protected and discipled him, and an amazing resolve to follow Christ at any cost.
How Wario acquired copies of the Scripture, growing up in a Muslim community, let alone heard about the truth of Jesus and eventually received Him, is an incredible demonstration of God’s providence. From a memory seared for life by emotional and physical travail, Wario relates the potentially life-threatening experiences he faced, simply because he decided not to be a Muslim.
Apologist Ravi Zacharias said that a person must be free to disbelieve or he or she is not truly free. This is Wario’s story. Though the Kenyan national constitution guaranteed his civil right to freedom of religion, his religious community recognized no such liberty. For his family, for his tribal relatives, for his fellow students at several schools, Wario’s rejection of Islam in favor of Christianity was tantamount to treason and deserving of forced re-conversion to Islam—or death.
When despite all odds Wario graduated at the top of his class he obtained employment translating the Orma language. And he emerged as a notable debater with Muslim contacts and clerics who would at least listen and perhaps respond without violence. A short time later through another series of providential provisions Wario secured a passport, traveled to the United States, and eventually completed a Bachelor’s Degree in Religion at Hope College in Michigan. As a 30-something Wario now lives in the United States and travels and speaks regularly about Islam and Christianity.
This book is both engaging and moving. You cannot learn about the challenge, risk, and total commitment of Wario’s young Christian life without comparing it to your own, which if it’s like mine, entailed no persecution and certainly no threat to life or limb. Reading the book makes you grateful once again for spiritual liberty in Christ and for political/personal liberty in a free society.
Wario concludes with two useful chapters examining controversial and vastly important topics: the Islamic depiction of Jesus Christ and the Islamic presentation of Prophet Muhammad as the Promised Comforter (the Holy Spirit). With his understanding of the Qur’an and the aHadith (sayings of Muhammad) as well as the Bible, Wario provides an articulate and concise resource for anyone wishing to learn more about Islam and how to speak respectfully and lovingly, but accurately, with Muslim friends.
I highly recommend this book. I cannot say that it is “enjoyable” to read because much of Wario’s story is heart-wrenching. But his story is an authentic reminder that God is great and his Son Jesus died and rose again for all who seek and received him. It’s also a reminder that American Christians must become wiser and more conversant in the ways of Islam so that we may properly engage Muslims spiritually and politically at home and abroad.
© Rex M. Rogers – All Rights Reserved, 2010
This blog may be reproduced in whole or in part but with a full attribution statement. Contact Dr. Rogers or read more commentary on current issues and events at www.rexmrogers.com or follow him at www.twitter.com/rexmrogers.
I’ve read more than one column written by an American Christian decrying Middle East Islamic violence in reaction to recent cartoons of Muhammad in the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten. I understand their criticism of the violence. It saddens me too, and I agree that it should be condemned by all good thinking people worldwide.
I also understand the Christian writers’ disagreement with certain basic tenets of Islam. My Christian theology doesn’t match Islamic theology either. I understand the writers’ tendency to list differences in Muhammad and Christ, for the differences define the distance between man and God.
I also understand the shake-your-head amazement at what many Americans, of the Christian faith or not, consider the emotional Muslim over-reaction to twelve cartoons. We can’t comprehend it. We’ve weathered The Last Temptation of Christ, The Da Vinci Code, postmodern sacrilegious art, and the ACLU’s latest pique about the Ten Commandments or Nativity scenes on courthouse lawns. It’s not that we don’t care about our faith or its icons. It’s just that we’ve learned a little bit about living in a religiously pluralistic democracy.
But there is one thing I do not understand—smug condemnation. What I must caution, at least for myself, is a too self-righteous response. Sadly, tragically, history offers us way too many examples of people acting just as emotionally, just as violently in the name of Christianity. They’ve tortured, they’ve crusaded, and they’ve killed unjustly. I don’t think this fact besmirches Christian truth or the character of God, but I do think it should cause us to speak with a bit of humility. People are people, Christians included, and those who name the name of Christ have not always acted in a Christ-like manner.
So I am not condoning violent Muslim reaction to cartoons, nor am I saying Christianity is anything less than a faith that focuses upon the Sovereign God of the Bible, the Creator God of the Universe. I’m just saying Christians don’t always act like Christians, me included.
© Rex M. Rogers - All Rights Reserved, 2006
*This blog may be reproduced in whole or in part with a full attribution statement. Contact Dr. Rogers or read more commentary on current issues and events at www.rexmrogers.com or follow him at www.twitter.com/rexmrogers.